This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $150! (May vary for Expedited Shipping).

Cart 0

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $150 away from free shipping.
No more products available for purchase

Products
Pair with
Is this a gift?
Subtotal Free
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty

Home
SALE
Collections
Categories
Mermen & Mermaids
Gift Cards
Our Story
Testimonials
Contact Us

Products 735

Filters

Availability
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
Color
More options
Category
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s 1 Reale Coin- Atocha Shipwreck Coins pendant showcases intricate oval details on a delicate sterling silver chain, set against a black backdrop, exuding a historic charm akin to cherished Atocha coins.
 
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s 1 Reale Coin- Atocha Shipwreck Coins pendant showcases intricate oval details on a delicate sterling silver chain, set against a black backdrop, exuding a historic charm akin to cherished Atocha coins.
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s 1 Reale Coin- Atocha Shipwreck Pendant is a historic piece featuring intricate markings on a sterling silver round pendant with a black background, suspended from a thin, textured chain.

1 Reale Coin- Atocha Shipwreck Coins (Pendant Only)

$179.00
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s 500 Museum Replica Coin pendant, featuring Atocha Shipwreck design, is set in a four-pronged sterling silver setting. The antique-style piece hangs elegantly from a twisted chain against a black backdrop.
 
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s 500 Museum Replica Coin pendant, featuring Atocha Shipwreck design, is set in a four-pronged sterling silver setting. The antique-style piece hangs elegantly from a twisted chain against a black backdrop.
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s 500 Museum Replica Coin, inspired by Atocha Shipwreck Coins, showcases a silver pendant with worn engravings and an elegant wire setting. It stands out against a black background with its antique appearance enhanced by a sterling silver bezel.

500 Museum Replica Coin- Atocha Shipwreck Coins (Pendant Only)

$359.00
The 502 Coin pendant from The Treasure Shoppe Inc. is a sterling silver piece resembling an antique Atocha shipwreck coin, featuring a cross and shield design. Its historic charm shines against a black background, hanging from a textured chain.
 
The 502 Coin pendant from The Treasure Shoppe Inc. is a sterling silver piece resembling an antique Atocha shipwreck coin, featuring a cross and shield design. Its historic charm shines against a black background, hanging from a textured chain.
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s 502 Coin pendant, reminiscent of Atocha shipwreck coins, features intricate ancient-style engravings on sterling silver. The design is highlighted by a twisted chain and black background to showcase its historic charm.

502 Coin- Atocha Shipwreck Coins (Pendant Only)

$249.00
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s 8 Reale 2 Prong Coin-Atocha Shipwreck Pendant boasts intricate designs in a simple metal frame. It dangles from a twisted sterling silver bezel chain against a black background, reminiscent of Atocha Coins.
 
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s 8 Reale 2 Prong Coin-Atocha Shipwreck Pendant boasts intricate designs in a simple metal frame. It dangles from a twisted sterling silver bezel chain against a black background, reminiscent of Atocha Coins.
On a black backdrop, a round silver pendant from The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s 8 Reale 2 Prong Coin-Atocha Shipwreck Coins collection hangs in a twisted sterling silver bezel. Resembling Atocha Coins, its secured by four brackets and showcases intricate symbols and patterns for an antique look.

8 Reale 2 Prong Coin-Atocha Shipwreck Coins (Pendant Only)

$229.00
Explore The Treasure Shoppe Inc.’s 8 Reale Shark Coin: a stunning silver pendant featuring a shark design around an ancient coin, set in sterling silver. The engraved coin hangs elegantly, offering timeless elegance.
 
Explore The Treasure Shoppe Inc.’s 8 Reale Shark Coin: a stunning silver pendant featuring a shark design around an ancient coin, set in sterling silver. The engraved coin hangs elegantly, offering timeless elegance.
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s 8 Reale Shark Coin Pendant, crafted in sterling silver, features a shark motif over a round Atocha shipwreck coin with cross-like symbols. The intricate metalwork stands out against its black background and comes with a braided chain for wearing.

8 Reale Shark Coin- Atocha Shipwreck Coins (Pendant Only)

$299.00
The Treasure Shoppe Inc. presents the 8 Reale Triple Prong Coin Pendant, inspired by Atocha shipwreck coins. This pendant showcases intricate patterns and historic charm, reminiscent of Atocha coins, beautifully dangles from a textured chain against a black background (chain not included).
 
The Treasure Shoppe Inc. presents the 8 Reale Triple Prong Coin Pendant, inspired by Atocha shipwreck coins. This pendant showcases intricate patterns and historic charm, reminiscent of Atocha coins, beautifully dangles from a textured chain against a black background (chain not included).
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s 8 Reale Triple Prong Coin pendant showcases an ornate, engraved circular design with symbols and numbers, evoking historic charm. The sterling silver piece hangs elegantly on a twisted chain against a black background.

8 Reale Triple Prong Coin- Atocha Shipwreck Coins (Pendant Only)

$229.00
The Alyssa Sky Blue Earrings by Holly Yashi feature elongated blue ovals with gold floral patterns, leaf and flower accents, and hand-colored niobium, shown on a white textured background.
 
The Alyssa Sky Blue Earrings by Holly Yashi feature elongated blue ovals with gold floral patterns, leaf and flower accents, and hand-colored niobium, shown on a white textured background.
A woman with blonde wavy hair smiles in a garden of white flowers and greenery, wearing Holly Yashi’s Alyssa Sky Blue Earrings and a light blue floral dress.

Alyssa Sky Blue Earrings- Holly Yashi

$89.98
The Anchors Away Ornament by December Diamonds features a shirtless merman with a white tail, sailor hat, sunglasses, and an anchor tattoo. Set against a water backdrop, it makes for unique holiday decor or a whimsical collection piece.
 

Anchors Away Ornament

$39.98
The Architectural Light Turquoise Bracelet by Firefly features rectangular blue gemstones with pink accents, handmade in Guatemala, and is showcased on a white cushioned stand.
 
The Architectural Light Turquoise Bracelet by Firefly features rectangular blue gemstones with pink accents, handmade in Guatemala, and is showcased on a white cushioned stand.
The Architectural Light Turquoise Bracelet by Firefly Jewelry, handmade in Guatemala, showcases multicolored rectangular stones on a silver band, with a dangling blue bead and metal tag near the clasp, displayed on a white cushion.

Architectural Light Turquoise Bracelet - Firefly Jewelry

$159.00
The Architectural Light Turquoise Earrings by Firefly Jewelry feature handmade, rectangular designs with blue, purple, and pink gemstones in a silver frame. These striking earrings hang elegantly from short hooks and reflect fair-trade practices.
 

Architectural Light Turquoise Earrings - Firefly Jewelry

$68.98
The Firefly Architectural Light Turquoise Necklace features a silver chain with a vertical rectangular pendant adorned with multicolored, iridescent blue, pink, and teal stones. Handmade in Guatemala, its hypo-allergenic and eye-catching.
 
The Firefly Architectural Light Turquoise Necklace features a silver chain with a vertical rectangular pendant adorned with multicolored, iridescent blue, pink, and teal stones. Handmade in Guatemala, its hypo-allergenic and eye-catching.
The Architectural Light Turquoise Necklace by Firefly Jewelry features a vertical, rectangular design with vibrant blue, purple, and pink gemstones elegantly set in a silver frame. This hypo-allergenic piece is handmade in Guatemala, hanging gracefully from a silver chain.

Architectural Light Turquoise Necklace – Firefly Jewelry

$59.98
The Aster Earrings/ Midnight Blue by Holly Yashi feature fan-shaped gold hooks, a gold sunburst design, rhinestones, and a marbled midnight blue lower half. Hypoallergenic for comfort. Shown on a white textured background.
 
The Aster Earrings/ Midnight Blue by Holly Yashi feature fan-shaped gold hooks, a gold sunburst design, rhinestones, and a marbled midnight blue lower half. Hypoallergenic for comfort. Shown on a white textured background.
A close-up shows a woman with blonde hair tucked behind her ear, wearing the Holly Yashi Aster Earrings in Midnight Blue—hypoallergenic statement earrings with a gold, fan-shaped top and wave-like bottom.

Aster Earrings/ Midnight Blue- Holly Yashi

$150.00
The Aster Necklace-Gold Necklace by Holly Yashi features a sunburst design with jagged rays and sparkling crystals, radiating golden brilliance against a plain white background.
 
The Aster Necklace-Gold Necklace by Holly Yashi features a sunburst design with jagged rays and sparkling crystals, radiating golden brilliance against a plain white background.
A woman with wavy blonde hair smiles, wearing a navy top and the Holly Yashi Aster Necklace-Gold Necklace, which features a sunburst design, along with large gold dangle earrings accented with shimmering blue crystal stones.

Aster Necklace-Gold Necklace- Holly Yashi

$130.00
The Atlantica Ornament by December Diamonds showcases a mermaid with long brown hair in a green and gold scale outfit, holding a gemstone-adorned trident against a shimmering water backdrop, ideal for holiday decor and creating an enchanting aquatic scene.
 

Atlantica Ornament

$39.98
The Atlantis Ornament by December Diamonds features a merman with long hair and beard, wearing a green scaled tail and golden ornaments. Holding a trident in the ocean, his hand-painted details make him ideal for holiday decor.
 

Atlantis Ornament

$39.98
Set against a black backdrop, The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s sterling silver Atocha 302 Coin pendant captures the historical essence of Atocha shipwreck coins. Its worn engravings feature a central cross with indistinct details, elegantly hanging from the thin silver chain.
 
Set against a black backdrop, The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s sterling silver Atocha 302 Coin pendant captures the historical essence of Atocha shipwreck coins. Its worn engravings feature a central cross with indistinct details, elegantly hanging from the thin silver chain.
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s Atocha 302 Coin Pendant resembles a mysterious Sterling silver Atocha coin with symbolic inscriptions set in a cross-shaped frame. Hanging elegantly against a black background, it whispers tales of historical significance.

Atocha 302 Coin- Atocha Shipwreck Coins (Pendant Only)

$239.00
The Treasure Shoppe Inc.s Atocha Coin Gold Plated Earrings, featuring historic charm with gold accents, hang elegantly on hooks and are displayed on a black stand against a dark textured background.
 

Atocha Coin Gold Plated Earrings- Atocha Shipwreck Coins

$225.00
The Auggie Ornament by December Diamonds features a bearded merman in a light blue St. Augustine tank top, lounging with a pink drink amid hand-painted palm leaves—ideal for holiday decor or mermaid ornament collectors.
 

Auggie Ornament

$39.98
A bearded merman with a blue scaly tail holds a globe on his shoulder, smiling. A peace sign tattoo on his arm exudes tranquility in light blue waters. This enchanting scene inspires the Axis Ornament from December Diamonds, perfect for adding holiday magic to your decor.
 

Axis Ornament

$39.98
The Back Draft Ornament by December Diamonds features a merman with a muscular upper body and vibrant yellow fish tail, wearing a firefighters helmet and suspenders, confidently holding a hose against a water backdrop.
 

Back Draft Ornament

$39.98
Add sweet charm to your holiday decor with the Baking Santa Ornament by December Diamonds—a whimsical merman chef with a Santa beard, cupcake, ice cream, red-and-white striped tail, chef’s hat, and apron.
 

Baking Santa Ornament

$39.98
The hand-painted Bathing Beauty Ornament from December Diamonds boasts a red vintage-style swimsuit with white accents, a blue and white striped hat, and a coordinating beach ball, encapsulating holiday decor essence against a water-like backdrop.
 

Bathing Beauty Ornaments

$39.98
The Baywitched Ornament by December Diamonds is a whimsical holiday decor piece featuring a pink-dressed witch with a black mermaid tail and broomstick, set against a water-themed backdrop. An exquisite blend of whimsical charm, its reminiscent of mystical mermaid ornaments.
 

Baywitched Ornament

$44.98
The Beach Bim Bo Ornament by December Diamonds features a bearded merman with a pink mermaid tail and blue floral shirt, set against a water-themed background—perfect for your holiday decor or mermaid collection.
 

Beach Bim Bo Ornament

$39.98